Module polkadot_sdk_docs::meta_contributing

Meta information about this crate, how it is built, what principles dictates its evolution and how one can contribute to it.

Contribution

The following sections cover more detailed information about this crate and how it should be maintained.

Why Rust Docs?

We acknowledge that blockchain based systems, particularly a cutting-edge one like Polkadot SDK is a software artifact that is complex, and rapidly evolving. This makes the task of documenting it externally extremely difficult, especially with regards to making sure it is up-to-date.

Consequently, we argue that the best hedge against this is to move as much of the documentation near the source code as possible. This would further incentivize developers to keep the documentation up-to-date, as the overhead is reduced by making sure everything is in one repository, and everything being in .rs files.

This is not to say that a more visually appealing version of this crate (for example as an md-book) cannot exist, but it would be outside the scope of this crate.

Moreover, we acknowledge that a major pain point has been not only outdated concepts, but also outdated code. For this, we commit to making sure no code-snippet in this crate is left as ///ignore or ///no_compile, making sure all code snippets are self-contained, compile-able, and correct at every single revision of the entire repository.

This also allows us to have a clear versioning on the entire content of this crate. For every commit of the Polkadot SDK, there would be one version of this crate that is guaranteed to be correct.

To achieve this, we often use docify, a nifty invention of @sam0x17.

Also see: https://github.com/paritytech/polkadot-sdk/issues/991.

Scope

The above would NOT be attainable if we don’t acknowledge that the scope of this crate MUST be limited, or else its maintenance burden would be infeasible or not worthwhile. In short, future maintainers should always strive to keep the content of this repository as minimal as possible. Some of the following principles are specifically there to be the guidance for this.

Principles

The following guidelines are meant to be the guiding torch of those who contribute to this crate.

1. 🔺 Ground Up: Information should be laid out in the most ground-up fashion. The lowest level (i.e. “ground”) is Rust-docs. The highest level (i.e. “up”) is “outside of this crate”. In between lies reference_docs and guides, from low to high. The point of this principle is to document as much of the information as possible in the lower level media, as it is easier to maintain and more reachable. Then, use excessive linking to back-link when writing in a more high level.

A prime example of this, the details of the FRAME storage APIs should NOT be explained in a high level tutorial. They should be explained in the rust-doc of the corresponding type or macro.

2. 🧘 Less is More: For reasons mentioned above, the more concise this crate is, the better.
3. √ Don’t Repeat Yourself – DRY: A summary of the above two points. Authors should always strive to avoid any duplicate information. Every concept should ideally be documented in ONE place and one place only. This makes the task of maintaining topics significantly easier.

A prime example of this, the list of CLI arguments of a particular binary should not be documented in multiple places across this crate. It should be only be documented in the corresponding crate (e.g. sc_cli).

Moreover, this means that as a contributor, it is your responsibility to have a grasp over what topics are already covered in this crate, and how you can build on top of the information that they already pose, rather than repeating yourself.

For more details see the latest documenting guidelines.

Example: Explaining #[pallet::call]

Let's consider the seemingly simple example of explaining to someone dead-simple code of a FRAME call and see how we can use the above principles.

#[frame::pallet(dev_mode)]
pub mod pallet {
    #[pallet::call]
    impl<T: Config> Pallet<T> {
        pub fn a_simple_call(origin: OriginFor<T>, data: u32) -> DispatchResult {
            ensure!(data > 10, "SomeStaticString");
            todo!();
        }
    }
}

• Before even getting started, what is with all of this <T: Config>? We link to crate::reference_docs::trait_based_programming.
• First, the name. Why is this called pallet::call? This goes back to enum Call, which is explained in crate::reference_docs::frame_runtime_types. Build on top of this!
• Then, what is origin? Just an account id? crate::reference_docs::frame_origin.
• Then, what is DispatchResult? Why is this called dispatch? Probably something that can be explained in the documentation of frame::prelude::DispatchResult.
• Why is "SomeStaticString" a valid error? Because there is implementation for it that you can see here.

All of these are examples of underlying information that a contributor should:

1. Try and create and they are going along.
2. Back-link to if they already exist.

Of course, all of this is not set in stone as a either/or rule. Sometimes, it is necessary to rephrase a concept in a new context.

docs.substrate.io

This crate is meant to gradually replace docs.substrate.io. As any content is added here, the corresponding counter-part should be marked as deprecated, as described here.

crates.io and Publishing

As it stands now, this crate cannot be published to crates.io because of its use of workspace-level docify. For now, we accept this compromise, but in the long term, we should work towards finding a way to maintain different revisions of this crate.

Versioning

So long as not deployed in crates.io, please notice that all of the information in this crate, namely in crate::guides and such are compatible with the master branch of polkadot-sdk. A few solutions have been proposed to improve this, please see here.

How to Develop Locally

To view the docs specific crate locally for development, including the correct HTML headers injected, run:

SKIP_WASM_BUILD=1 \
RUSTDOCFLAGS="--html-in-header $(pwd)/docs/sdk/assets/header.html --extend-css $(pwd)/docs/sdk/assets/theme.css --default-theme=ayu" \
cargo doc -p polkadot-sdk-docs --no-deps --open

If even faster build time for docs is needed, you can temporarily remove most of the substrate/cumulus dependencies that are only used for linking purposes.

For more on local development, see crate::reference_docs::development_environment_advice.